Marketing the ‘Slippery’ Local with the Contrived ‘Rural’: Case Studies of Alternative Vegetable Retail in the Urban Fringe of Nagoya, Japan

##plugins.themes.bootstrap3.article.main##

##plugins.themes.bootstrap3.article.sidebar##

Published Jun 4, 2010
Aaron Kingsbury Yosuke Maeda Makoto Takahashi

Abstract

In recent years, a wealth of research has been conducted on alternative food economies and the construction of quality in markets in North America and Europe. Nonetheless, research undertaken from these perspectives on food networks in the Japanese context remains relatively unexplored. As the definition of quality is rooted in the social, political and economic contexts of particular places, understanding its construction requires empirical studies on actual alternative food economies in Japan. In efforts to partially address this gap, this article focuses on how re-embedded and possibly appropriated alternative food economies (re-)?valorize and then combine ‘locality’ with ‘rurality’ in farm product retail outlets in the Nagoya urban fringe. The authors conducted a series of interviews with retailers who source ‘locally’ produced vegetables from outside the Central Union of Agricultural Co-operatives to assess their goals, supply strategies and marketing images. The semantics of ‘local’ was found to be highly malleable based on retail imperatives, but its visualization through the photographic depiction of farmers was found to be a salient element in the construction and marketing of ‘quality’ to consumers.

How to Cite

Kingsbury, A. ., Maeda, Y. . and Takahashi, M. (2010) “Marketing the ‘Slippery’ Local with the Contrived ‘Rural’: Case Studies of Alternative Vegetable Retail in the Urban Fringe of Nagoya, Japan”, The International Journal of Sociology of Agriculture and Food. Paris, France, 17(2), pp. 89–107. doi: 10.48416/ijsaf.v17i2.261.
Abstract 218 | PDF Downloads 143

##plugins.themes.bootstrap3.article.details##

References
AICHI PREFECTURAL GOVERNMENT (2005) Statistical Yearbook. Published online /toukei>, accessed on 10 october 2007.
ARCHER, G.P., SANCHEZ, J., VIGNALI, G. and CHAILLOT, A. (2003) Latent consumers’ attitude to farmers’ markets
in north West england, British Food Journal, 105(8), pp. 487–497.
BENEDIKTSSON, K. (2001) Beyond productivism: regulatory changes and their outcomes in Icelandic farming,
in: K. KIM, I. BOWLER and C. BRYANT (eds) Proceedings of the IGU-CSRS Conference in Developing
Sustainable Rural Systems 2000, Pusan: Pusan national University Press, pp. 75–87.
BROWN, A. (2002) Farmers’ market research 1940–2000: an inventory and review, American Journal of Alternative
Agriculture, 17(4), pp. 167–176.
DE LIND, L. (2002) Place, work, and civic agriculture: common fields for cultivation’, Agriculture and Human
Values, 19, pp. 217–224.
DOWLER, E. and CARAHER, M. (2003) Local food projects: the new philanthropy?, Political Quarterly, 74(1),
pp. 57–65.
EVANS, N., MORRIS, C. and WINTER, M. (2002) Conceptualizing agriculture: a critique of post-productivism
as the new orthodoxy, Progress in Human Geography, 26, pp. 313–332.
GODO, Y. (2001) The Changing Economic Performance and Political Significance of Japan’s Agricultural Cooperatives,
east Asia Bureau of economic research Working Papers no. 318. Canberra: Australian national
University.
GRANOVETTER, M. (1985) economic action and social structure: the problem of embeddedness, American
Journal of Sociology, 91(3), pp. 481–510.
HEBBERT, M. (1994) Sen-biki amidst desakota: urban sprawl and urban planning in Japan, in: P. SHAPRIRA,
I. MASSER and D.W. EDGINTON (eds) Planning for Cities and Regions in Japan, Liverpool: Liverpool University
Press, pp. 70–91.
HINRICHS, C. (2000) embeddedness and local food systems: notes on two types of direct agricultural market,
Journal of Rural Studies, 16(3) pp. 295–303.
HINRICHS, C., GILLESPIE, G. and FEENSTRA, G. (2004) Social learning and innovation at retail farmers’ markets,
Rural Sociology, 69(1), pp. 31–58.
HOLLOWAY, L. and KNEAFSEY, M. (2000) reading the space of the farmers’ market: a case study from the
United Kingdom, Sociologia Ruralis, 40, pp. 285–299.
IGA, M. (2006) Symposium II: new trends in food geography: food quality and food network approaches,
Geographical Review of Japan, english edition, 1, pp. 269–270.
IGA, M. (2007) Constructions of raw materials’ quality in miso supply networks, Geographical Review of
Japan, 80(6), pp. 361–381 (in Japanese).
ILBERY, B. and KNEAFSEY, M. (1999) niche markets and regional specialty food products in europe: towards
a research agenda, Environment and Planning A, 31, pp. 2307–2322.
ILBERY, B. and KNEAFSEY, M. (2000) Producer constructions of quality in regional specialty food production:
a case study from South West england, Journal of Rural Studies, 16(2), pp. 217–230.
ISODA, Y., MATSUOUKA, K. and KIM, D-C. (2001) Changes in agricultural land use in the Sendai metropolitan
area of Japan: 1970s–1990s, in: K. KIM, I. BOWLER and C. BRYANT (eds) Proceedings of the IGU-CSRS Conference
in Developing Sustainable Rural Systems 2000, Pusan: Pusan national University Press, pp. 413–421.
ITO, T. (2001) Self sustained evolution system of agriculture from the Japanese urban fringe experience, in:
K. KIM, I. BOWLER and C. BRYANT (eds) Proceedings of the IGU-CSRS Conference in Developing Sustainable
Rural Systems 2000, Pusan: Pusan national University Press, pp. 305–316.
ITO, T. (2004) Knowledge, learning system and self-sustained evolution of agriculture in central Japan, in:
Proceedings of the IGU Conference on Land Use and Rural Sustainability, Aberdeen, 10–14 August 2004, pp.
39–46.
ITO, T. (2009) on farm products direct sale place of agricultural cooperative association, Studies of Economics
and Business, 28, 1–32 (in Japanese).
JAPANESE STATISTICS BUREAU (2000) Population of Japan. Published online /data/kokusei/2000/final/hyodai.htm> accessed on 10 october 2007.
KIKUCHI, T. and CUI, T.W. (2001) Sustainable development of the corporate farm and its regional conditions
in the inner fringe of the tokyo metropolitan area, in: K. KIM, I. BOWLER and C. BRYANT (eds) Proceedings
of the IGU-CSRS Conference in Developing Sustainable Rural Systems 2000, Pusan: Pusan national University
Press, pp. 279–291.
KIKUCHI, T., OISHI, T. and SAITOH, R. (2002) recreating of the rurality in the urban fringe of tokyo metropolitan
area: a case study of Kodaira City, Geographical Reports of Tokyo Metropolitan University, 37, pp.
93–102.
KIRWAN, J. (2004) Alternative strategies in the UK agro-food system: interrogating the alterity of farmers’
markets, Sociologia Ruralis, 44(4), pp. 395–415.
KITAHARA, A. (2004) Agrarian transformation and rural diversity in globalizing east Asia, International Journal
of Japanese Sociology, 13, pp. 7–21.
KOGANEZAWA, T. (2007) Development for agriculture in the region through food culture, Annals of the Association
of Economic Geographers, 53(1), pp. 98–118 (in Japanese).
KOHMOTO, D. (2005) Farmers’ attitudes toward promoted organic agriculture in transformation: the case
of Aya town, Kyushu, Japanese Journal of Human Geography, 57(1), pp. 1–24 (in Japanese).
KUMAGAI, H. (1996) Concept of sustainable and regional agriculture in Japan, in: H. SASAKI, I. SAITO, A.
TABAYASHI and T. MORIMOTO (eds) Proceedings of the Tsukuba International Conference on the Sustainability
of Rural Systems, Kaisei Publications: tokyo, pp. 36–43.
LA TROBE, H. (2001) Farmers’ markets: consuming local rural produce, International Journal of Consumer
Studies, 25(3), pp. 181–192.
MAFF (MINISTRY OFAGRICULTURE, FORESTRY, FISHERIES) (2007) Nation-wide Survey on the Project on Information
Exchange Network for Agriculture, Forestry and Fishery in 2006 – Survey Result on Attitudes toward Local
Products for Local Consumption. Published online /2007031201cyosa.pdf>, accessed on 15 April 2010.
MAFF (MINISTRY OF AGRICULTURE, FORESTRY, FISHERIES) (2008) Survey on Local Products for Local Consumption
of Farmer’s Products in 2007. Published online /index.html>, accessed on 15 April 2010.
MCDONALD, M. (1997) Agricultural landholding in Japan: fifty years after land reform, Geoforum, 28(1), pp.
55–78.
MIYACHI, T. (2007) regional deployment of organic agriculture in Japan and regional agriculture promotion,
Annals of the Japan Association of Economic Geographers, 53(1), pp. 41–60 (in Japanese).
MIZUSHIMA, K. (1996) Current situation of sustainable agriculture in Japan-geographical distribution and
characteristics of practicing examples of farm households and groups, in: H. SASAKI, I. SAITO, A.
TABAYASHI and T. MORIMOTO (eds) Proceedings of the Tsukuba International Conference on the Sustainability
of Rural Systems, tokyo: Kaisei Publications, pp. 36–43.
MOEN, D. (1997) the Japanese organic farming movement: consumers and farmers united, Bulletin of Concerned
Asian Scholars, 29(3), pp. 14–22.
MOEN, D. (2000) Grassroots-based organic food distributors, retailers, and consumer cooperatives in Japan:
broadening the organic farming movement, Hitotsubashi Journal of Social Sciences, 32, pp. 55–76.
MOORE, O. (2006) Understanding post-organic fresh fruit and vegetable consumers at participatory farmers’
markets in Ireland: reflexivity, trust and social movements, International Journal of Consumer Studies,
30(5), pp. 416–426.
MORI, H. (1998) Land conversion at the urban fringe: a comparative study of Japan, Britain, and the netherlands,
Urban Studies, 35(9), pp. 1541–1558.
MORIMOTO, T. (2001) Abandonment of cultivation in Japan in the 1970s–1990s: the case of the Kanto District,
in: K. KIM, I. BOWLER and C. BRYANT (eds) Proceedings of the IGU-CSRS Conference in Developing Sustainable
Rural Systems 2000, Pusan: Pusan national University Press, pp. 375-384
MORGAN, K. and MURDOCH, J. (2000) organic vs. conventional agriculture: knowledge, power and innovation
in the food chain, Geoforum, 31, pp. 159–173.
MORRIS, C. and BULLER, H. (2003) the local food sector: a preliminary assessment of its form and impact
in Gloucestershire, British Food Journal, 105(8), pp. 559–566.
MORRIS, C. and YOUNG, C. (2000) Seed to shelf, teat to table, barley to beer and womb to tomb: discourses
of food quality and quality assurance schemes in the UK, Journal of Rural Studies, 16(1), pp. 103–115.
MURDOCH, J. and MIELE, M. (1999) Back to nature: changing worlds of production in the food sector, Economic
Geography, 75, pp. 107–125.
MURDOCH, J., MARSDEN, T. and BANKS, J. (2000) Quality, nature, and embeddedness: some theoretical considerations
in the context of the food sector, Economic Geography, 76, pp. 107–125.
NAGAKI, M. (2002) Trends and Future Perspectives of Organized Farms in Japan. Presented at 13 IFMA-Congress
Special Session: the Farm as an enterprise, Wageningen, 7–12 July.
NAKAJIMA, M. (1996) Cultivation abandonment and sustainability of rice terraces in Japan, in: H. SASAKI,
I. SAITO, A. TABAYASHI and T. MORIMOTO (eds) Proceedings of the Tsukuba International Conference on the Sustainability
of Rural Systems, tokyo: Kaisei Publications, pp. 115–121.
OHE, Y. (2006) on the relationship between multifunctionality and hamlet activities as a rural institution,
Japanese Journal of Rural Economics, 8, pp. 41–57.
PARKER, G. (2005) Sustainable Food? Teikei, Co-operatives and Food Citizenship in Japan and the UK, Working
Papers in real estate and Planning. Department of real estate and Planning, University of reading.
RENTING, H., MARSDEN, T. and BANKS, J. (2003) Understanding alternative food networks: exploring the
role of short supply chains in rural development, Environment and Planning A, 35, pp. 393–411.
SAIZEN, I., MIZUNO, K. and KOBAYASHI, S. (2006) effects of land-use master plans in the metropolitan fringe
of Japan, Land and Urban Planning, 78, pp. 411–421.
SAKAMAKI, S. (1996a) From rice to ruin, Far Eastern Economic Review, 159(28), p. 60.
SAKAMAKI. S. (1996b) Planting ideas: Japanese farmers specialize to beat the free market, Far Eastern Economic
Review, 159(28), pp. 59–61.
SAKAMOTO, H. (1996) Some experiences of sustainable agriculture in Japan, in: H. SASAKI, I. SAITO, A.
TABAYASHI and T. MORIMOTO (eds) Proceedings of the Tsukuba International Conference on the Sustainability
of Rural Systems, tokyo: Kaisei Publications, pp. 203–209.
SAWA, M. and TAKAHASHI, M. (1996) Conceptualizing social changes of Japanese rurban villages: rural
diversification and interaction of social groups, in: H. SASAKI, I. SAITO, A. TABAYASHI and T. MORIMOTO
(eds) Proceedings of the Tsukuba International Conference on the Sustainability of Rural Systems, tokyo: Kaisei
Publications, pp. 44–49.
TABAYASHI, A. and WALDICHUK, T. (2004) Sustainability of villages involved in vegetable gardening in the
tokyo metropolitan area: a case study from the western part of Ibaraki Prefecture on the Kanto Plain of
Central Japan, in: Proceedings of the IGU Conference on Land Use and Rural Sustainability, Aberdeen, 10–
14 August 2004, pp. 102–108.
TAKAHASHI, M. (2001) Changing ruralities and the post-productivist countryside of Japan: policy changes
of the central government in the 1990s, in: K. KIM, I. BOWLER and C. BRYANT (eds) Proceedings of the IGUCSRS
Conference in Developing Sustainable Rural Systems 2000, Pusan: Pusan national University Press,
pp. 163–174.
TAKAHASHI, M. (2004) re-constructed rurality and identifying place in the Furano region of Japan, in: Proceedings
of the IGU Conference on Land Use and Rural Sustainability, Aberdeen, 10–14 August 2004, pp.
126–131.
TAKAHASHI, M. and NAKAGAWA, S. (2002) Features of association with the term ‘rural’, Journal of Rural Planning
Association, 21(2), pp. 143–152 (in Japanese).
TAKAHASHI, M. and SAWA, M. (1996) Conceptualizing social changes in Japanese rurban villages: the recomposition
of local community organizations, in: H. SASAKI, I. SAITO, A. TABAYASHI and T. MORIMOTO (eds)
Proceedings of the Tsukuba International Conference on the Sustainability of Rural Systems, tokyo: Kaisei Publications,
pp. 293–302.
TAKAYANAGI, N. (2007) Fabricating local embeddedness of foods: branded beef and revitalization of the
rural economy, Annals of the Japan Association of Economic Geographers, 53(1), pp. 61–77 (in Japanese).
TANNO, Y. (2007) Development of the hog industry and branded pork projects in Asahi Village, Ibaraki
Prefecture, Geographical Review of Japan, 80(6), pp. 382–394.
VENN, L., KNEAFSEY, M., HOLLOWAY, L., COX, R., DOWLER, E. and TUOMAINEN, H. (2006) researching european
‘alternative’ food networks: some methodological considerations, Area, 38(3), pp. 248–258.
WATTS, D., ILBERY, B. and MAYE, D. (2005) Making reconnections in agro-food geography: alternative systems
of food provision, Progress in Human Geography, 29(1), pp. 22–40.
WILSON, G. and RIGGS, J. (2003) Post-productivist agricultural regimes and the South: discordant concepts?,
Progress in Human Geography, 27(6), pp. 681–707.
WILTSHIRE, R. and AZUMA, R. (2000) rewriting the plot: sustaining allotments in the UK and Japan, Local
Environment, 5(2), pp. 139–151.
WINTER, M. (2003a) Geographies of food: agro-food geographies-making reconnections, Progress in Human
Geography, 27(4), pp. 505–513.
WINTER, M. (2003b) embeddedness, the new food economy and defensive localism, Journal of Rural Studies,
19, pp. 23–32.
YAMAMOTO, M. (1996) Sustainability of urban agriculture in the tokyo metropolitan area, in: H. SASAKI, I.
SAITO, A. TABAYASHI and T. MORIMOTO (eds) Proceedings of the Tsukuba International Conference on the Sustainability
of Rural Systems, tokyo: Kaisei Publications, pp. 262–269.
YOUNGS, J. (2003) A study of farm outlets in north west england, British Food Journal, 105, pp. 531–541.
Section
Articles