Neo-liberalism, the WTO and New Modes of Agri-environmental Governance in the European Union, the USA and Australia

##plugins.themes.bootstrap3.article.main##

##plugins.themes.bootstrap3.article.sidebar##

Published Jan 15, 2021
Mark Tilzey

Abstract

Neo-liberalism in agricultural policy has exhibited a growing presence in the ‘new global economy’, pursuing an agenda that seeks to dismantle the welfare components of established ‘national’ policies and to re-construct in their stead a new ‘post-Fordist’ accumulation dynamic and novel structures of governance simultaneously at regional and global levels.

The WTO constitutes a key site for the re-regulation of international governance in favour of neo-liberalism, a process in which state intervention to underwrite agricultural production and environmental and social protection is deemed increasingly inadmissible where market ‘distortion’ is implied.

Nevertheless, the implantation of neo-liberalism in agricultural policy exhibits considerable unevenness between states, being characterised by varying levels of accommodation and resistance. States appear to be seeking accumulation opportunities through liberalisation whilst simultaneously, and in varying degrees, striving to sustain some level of agricultural and socio-environmental ‘exceptionalism’ in policy, often manifested in new modes of agri-environmental governance.

The nature and causal bases for these new modes of ‘post-Fordist’ governance are explored with reference to the European Union, the USA and Australia.

How to Cite

[1]
Tilzey, M. 2021. Neo-liberalism, the WTO and New Modes of Agri-environmental Governance in the European Union, the USA and Australia . The International Journal of Sociology of Agriculture and Food. 14, (Jan. 2021), 1-28. DOI:https://doi.org/10.48416/ijsaf.v14i.303.
Abstract 47 | PDF Downloads 24

##plugins.themes.bootstrap3.article.details##

References
AgraEurope 2004 WTO Framework Deal Puts Doha Round Back on Track, AgraEurope, No 2117, August 6.
Archer, M and Beale, B 2004 Going Native: Living in the Australian Environment. Hodder: Sydney.
Altieri, M 1987 Agro-ecology: The Scientific Basis of Alternative Agriculture. Westview Press: Boulder.
Ayer, H and Swinbank, A 2002 The 2002 US Farm Bill: What’s in it for the CAP and WTO Reform, Eurochoices Winter.
Bernstein, S 2002 The Compromise of Liberal Environmentalism. Columbia University Press: New York.
Blandford, D 2002 A US Perspective on the Current Round of Agricultural Trade Negotiations, paper for the International Postgraduate Course, Wageningen University.
Bieler, A and Morton, A (eds) 2001 Social Forces in the Making of the New Europe: the Restructuring of European Social Relations in the Global Political Economy. Palgrave: Basingstoke.
Bohmann, M et al. 1999 The Use and Abuse of Multifunctionality. ERS, USDA: Washington DC.
Botterill, L 2004 Farm Groups and Policy Change: the Agricultural Policy Community in Australia and the EU. Mimeo.
Bryan, R 1987 The State and Internationalisation of Capital: an Approach to Analysis, Journal of Contemporary Asia, 17, 253-275.
Buckwell, A 2004 Interview. CLA, London.
Burkett, P 1999 Marx and Nature: a Red and Green Perspective. Macmillan: Basingstoke.
Buttel, F 1989 The US Farm Crisis and the Restructuring of American Agriculture: Domestic and International Dimensions, in Goodman, D and Redclift, M (eds) The International Farm Crisis. Macmillan: Basingstoke.
Buttel, F 1997 Some Observations on Agro-Food Change and the Future of Agricultural Sustainability Movements, in Goodman, D and Watts, M (eds) Globalising Food: Agrarian Questions and Global Restructuring. Routledge: London.
Buttel, F 2003 Continuities and Conjunctures in the Transformation of the US Agro-Food System, in Brown, D and Swanson, L (eds) Challenges for Rural America in the 21st Century. Penn State Press: University Park, Pennsylvania.
Cafruny, A 1989 Economic Conflicts and the Transformation of the Atlantic Order: the US, Europe, and the Liberalisation of Agriculture and Services, in Gill, S (ed) Atlantic Relations beyond the Reagan Era. St Martin’s Press: New York.
Choplin, G 2003 Interview. CPE, Brussels.
Coates, D 2000 Models of Capitalism: Growth and Stagnation in the Modern Era. Polity: Cambridge.
Cocklin, C 2005 Natural Capital and the Sustainability of Rural Communities, in Cocklin, C and Dibden, J (eds) Sustainability and Change in Rural Australia. UNSW Press: Sydney.
Coleman, W 1998 From Protected Development to Market Liberalism: Paradigm Change in Agriculture, Journal of Public Policy, 5, 4, 632-651.
Coleman, W, Grant, W and Josling, T 2004 Agriculture in the New Global Economy. Edward Elgar: Cheltenham.
CPE 2001 To Change the CAP. CPE, Brussels.
Cowan, T 2002 The Changing Structure of Agriculture and Rural America: Emerging Opportunities and Challenges. Novinka: New York.
Cox, R 1987 Production, Power and World Order: Social Forces in the Making of History. Columbia University Press: New York.
Dibden, J and Cocklin, C 2005 Sustainability and Agri-environmental Governance, in Higgins, V and Lawrence, G (eds) Agricultural Governance: Globalization and the New Politics of Regulation. Routledge: London
Dixon, D and Hapke, H 2003 Cultivating Discourse: the Social Construction of Agricultural Legislation, Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 93, 1, 142-164.
Drummond, I and Marsden, T 1999 The Condition of Sustainability. Routledge: London.
Drummond, I et al 2000 Contingent or Structural Crisis in British Agriculture? Sociologia Ruralis 40, 1, 111-127.
European Landowners Organisation 2004 Third Generation Agriculture. ELO: Brussels.
Fagan, R and Le Heron, R 1994 Reinterpreting the Geography of Accumulation: the Global Shift and Local Restructuring, Environment and Planning D: Society and Space, 12, 265-285.
Figgis, P 2003 The Changing Face of Nature Conservation: Reflections on the Australian Experience, in Adams, W and Mulligan, M (eds) Decolonizing Nature: Strategies for Conservation in a Post-Colonial Era. Earthscan: London.
Fynn, J 2003 Interview. WTO, Geneva.
Gill, S 1990 American Hegemony and the Trilateral Commission. Cambridge University Press: Cambridge.
Goodman, D, Sorj, J and Wilkinson, D 1989 From Farming to Biotechnology. Blackwell: Oxford.
Grafen, A and Schramek, J 2000 Germany: Complex Agri-environmental Policy in a Federal System, in Buller, H, Wilson, G and Holl, A (eds) Agri-environmental Policy in the European Union. Ashgate: Aldershot.
Gray, I and Lawrence, G 2001 A Future for Regional Australia: Escaping Global Misfortune. Cambridge University Press: Sydney.
Hart, M 1997 The WTO and the Political Economy of Globalisation, Journal of World Trade, 31, 5, 75-94
Hennis, M 2002 New Transatlantic Conflicts: American and European Food Policies Compared. RSC No 2002/1 Robert Schuman Centre for Advanced Studies, European University Institute, Florence.
Herman, P and Kuper, R 2003 Food for Thought: Towards a Future for Farming. Pluto Press: London.
Hodge, I 2000 Agri-environmental Relationships, The World Economy, 23, 2, 257-273.
Hoefner, F 2003 Interview. Sustainable Agriculture Coalition, Washington DC.
Hoefner, F 2004 Interview. Sustainable Agriculture Coalition, Washington DC.
Hollander, G 2004 Agricultural Trade Liberalization, Multifunctionality, and Sugar in the South Florida Landscape, Geoforum, 35, 3, 299-312.
Ingersent, K and Rayner, A 1999 Agricultural Policy in Western Europe and the United States. Edward Elgar: Cheltenham.
International Institute for Sustainable Development 2002 Agri-Environment and Rural Development in the Doha Round. IISD: Geneva.
Jessop, B 2002 The Future of the Capitalist State. Polity Press: Cambridge.
Josling, T 2002 Globalisation and Transnational Corprorations, Moss, C et al (eds) Agricultural Globalisation, Trade and the Environment. Kluwer: Dordrecht.
Keeler, J 1996 Agricultural Power in the European Community: Explaining the Fate of the CAP and GATT Negotiations, Comparative Politics, 28, 127-149.
Larner, W and Le Heron, R 2002 From Economic Globalisation to Globalising Economic Processes: Towards Post-Structural Political Economies, Geoforum, 33, 415-419.
Lawrence, G 1989 The Rural Crisis Downunder: Australia’s Declining Fortunes in the Global Farm Economy, in Goodman, D and Redclift, M (eds) The International Farm Crisis. Macmillan: Basingstoke.
Lawrence, G 1990 Agricultural Restructuring and Rural Social Change in Australia, in Marsden, T et al. (eds) Rural Restructuring: Global Processes and their Responses. David Fulton: London.
Lawrence, G and Vanclay, F 1994 Agricultural Change in the Semi-periphery: the Murray-Darling Basin in Australia, in McMichael, P (ed) The Global Restructuring of Agri-Food Systems. Cornell University Press: Ithaca.
Lobao, L and Meyer, K 2001 The Great Agricultural Transition: Crisis, Change, and Social Consequences of Twentieth Century US Farming, Annual Review of Sociology, 27, 103-124.
Lockie, S and Bourke, L (eds) Rurality Bites: the Social and Environmental Transformation of Rural Australia. Pluto Press: Sydney.
Lowe, P et al. 2003 Setting the Agenda? British and French Approaches to the Second Pillar of the Common Agricultural Policy, Journal of Rural Studies 18, 1-19.
Martin, P and Ritchie, H 1999 Logics of Participation: Rural Environmental Governance under Neo-liberalism in Australia, Environmental Politics, 8, 2, 117-135.
McCarthy and Prudham, S 2004 Neoliberal Nature and the Nature of Neoliberalism, Geoforum, 35, 3, 275-283.
McMichael, P 2002 The Power of Food, Agriculture and Human Values, 17: 21-33.
McMichael, P 2004 Global Development and the Corporate Food Regime, paper presented to the Symposium on New Directions in the Sociology of Global Development, XI World Congress of Rural Sociology, Trondheim, July.
Moyer, W 2004 Agricultural Policy Change in the EU and the US, paper presented to the XI World Congress of Rural Sociology, Trondheim, July.
Murdoch, J et al 2003 The Differentiated Countryside. Routledge: London.
OECD 2001 Multifunctionality: Towards an Analytical Framework. OECD: Paris.
Orden, D 2002 The Farm Policy Reform Process, in Moss, C et al (eds) Agricultural Globalisation, Trade and the Environment. Kluwer: Dordrecht.
Orden, D 2003 US Agricultural Policy: the 2002 Farm Bill and the WTO Doha Round Proposal, Trade and Macro Economics Division, Division, International Food Policy Research Institute.
Orden, D et al. 1999 Policy Reform in American Agriculture. University of Chicago Press: Chicago.
Overbeek, H 1990 Global Capitalism and National Decline: the Thatcher Decade in Perspective. Unwin Hyman: London.
Overbeek, H and van der Pijl, K 1993 Restructuring Capital and Restructuring Hegemony: Neo-liberalism and the Unmaking of the Post-war Order, in Overbeek, H (ed) Restructuring Hegemony in Global Political Economy: the
Rise of Transnational Liberalism in the 1980s. Routledge: London.
Palloix, C 1977 The Self-Expansion of Capital on a World Scale, Review of Radical Political Economics, 9, 3-27.
Peine, E and McMichael, P 2005 Globalization and Global Governance, in Higgins, V and Lawrence, G (eds) Agricultural Governance: Globalization and the New Politics of Regulation. Routledge: London.
Petit, M 2002 The New US Farm Bill: Lessons from a Complete Ideological Turnaround, Eurochoices, Winter.
Petras, J and Veltmayer, H 2001 Globalization Unmasked: Imperialism in the 21st Century London: Zed Press; Harvey, D 2006 Spaces of Global Capitalism: towards a theory of uneven geographical development London: Verso.
Polanyi, K 1957 The Great Transformation: the Political and Economic Origins of Our Time. Beacon: New York.
Potter, C and Tilzey, M 2002 Agricultural Multifunctionality in the WTO: the Implications for the Design of EU Rural Policy, London: EPMG Imperial College London Working Paper
Potter, C and Tilzey, M 2005 Agricultural Policy Discourses in the European Post-Fordist Transition: Neo-liberalism, Neo-mercantilism and Multifunctionality, Progress in Human Geography 29, 5, 581- 601.
Pritchard, B 2000 Negotiating the Two-edged Sword of Agricultural Trade Liberalisation: Trade Policy and its Protectionist Discontents, in Pritchard, B and McManus, P (eds) Land of Discontent: the Dynamics of Change in Rural and Regional Australia. University of New South Wales Press: Sydney.
Pritchard, B 2005a Implementing and Maintaining Neoliberal Agriculture in Australia Part 1: Constructing neoliberalism as a vision for agricultural policy, International Journal of the Sociology of Agriculture and Food Pritchard, B 2005b Implementing and Maintaining Neoliberal Agriculture in Australia Part 2: Strategies for securing neoliberalism, International Journal of the Sociology of Agriculture and Food
Pritchard, B and McManus, P (eds) 2000 Land of Discontent: the Dynamics of Change in Rural and Regional Australia. University of New South Wales Press: Sydney.
Ritchie, M and Ristau, K 1986 US Farm Policy: the 1987 Debate, World Policy Journal, 4.
Rollo, J 2004 The Consequences of Mr Mandelson: EU Trade Policy and the New Commission, paper presented to the National Europe Centre, ANU, Public Seminar Series, November.
Ruigrok, W and van Tulder 1995 The Logic of International Restructuring: Management of Dependencies in Rival Industrial Complexes. Routledge: London.
Schmidt, V 2002 The Futures of European Capitalism. Oxford University Press: Oxford.
Sevilla Guzman, E and Woodgate, G 1999 From Farming Systems Research to Agroecology, in Technical and Social Systems Approaches for Sustainable Rural Development. European Commission: Brussels.
Sheingate, A 2000 Agricultural Retrenchment Revisited: Issue Definition and Venue Change in the United States and the European Union, Governance, 13, 3, 335-363.
Tangermann, S 2003 The WTO Doha Round: Prospects for Agriculture, Paper presented to the Royal Institute of International Affairs Conference on Food Production and the New Trade Agenda. Chatham House: London.
Tilzey, M 2000a Natural Areas, the Whole Countryside Approach and Sustainable Agriculture, Land Use Policy, 17, 279-294.
Tilzey, M 2000b Mapping Government Thinking on Globalisation. UK Food Group: London.
Tilzey, M 2002 Conservation and Sustainability, in Bowler, I et al (eds) The Sustainability of Rural Systems: Geographical Interpretations. Kluwer: Dordrecht.
Tilzey, M 2005 Agriculture, Trade and Multifunctionality: The Politico-Economic and Ecological Contexts for Post-Productivist Initiatives in Australia and the EU, National Europe Centre Working Paper, Australian National University.
Tilzey, M and Potter, C 2006a (forthcoming) Neo-liberalism, Neo-mercantilism, and Multifunctionality: Contested Political Discourses in European Post-Fordist Rural Governance, in Cheshire, L, Higgins, V and Lawrence, G (eds) International
Perspectives on Rural Governance: New Power Relations in Rural Economies and Societies. Routledge: London.
Tilzey, M and Potter, C 2006b (forthcoming) Productivism versus Post-Productivism? Neo-liberalism and Agri-environmental Governance in Post-Fordist Agricultural Transitions, in Robinson, G (ed) Sustainable Rural Systems: Sustainable Agriculture and Rural Communities. Ashgate: Aldershot.
Van Apeldoorn, B 2002 Transnational Capitalism and the Struggle over European Integration. Routledge: London.
Van der Pijl, K 1998 Transnational Classes and International Relations. Routledge: London.
Van Huylenbroeck, G and Durand, G (eds) 2003 Multifunctional Agriculture: A New Paradigm for European Agriculture and Rural Development. Ashgate: Aldershot.
Via Campesina 2001 Our World is not For Sale. Priority to Peoples’ Food Sovereignty, Bulletin, November 1.
Via Campesina 2003 Statement on Agriculture after Cancun, Bulletin, December 15.
Vorley, B 2004 Global Food Chains – Constraints and Opportunities for Smallholders, DfID: London.
Ward, N 2003 Environmental Policy Integration and Agriculture in Britain and Europe, paper presented to the National Europe Centre Conference Environmental Policy Integration and Sustainable Development. ANU: Canberra.
Webber, D 1999 Franco-German Bilateralism and Agricultural Politics in the European Union, West European Politics, 22, 45-67.
Weiss, L 1998 The Myth of the Powerless State: Governing the Economy in a Global Era. Polity: Cambridge.
Whatmore, S 1994 Global Agro-food Complexes and the Refashioning of Rural Europe, in Amin, A and Thrift, N (eds) Globalisation, Institutions, and Regional Development in Europe. Oxford University Press: Oxford.
Williams, C 2004 Old Land, New Landscapes. University of Melbourne Press: Melbourne
Wills, J 2002 Political Economy III: Neoliberal Chickens, Seattle and Geography, Progress in Human Geography, 26, 90-100.
Wood, E 2005 Empire of Capital. Verso: London.
World Trade Organisation 2000 Agriculture. WTO: Geneva.
Zinn, J 1999 Conservation Spending in Agriculture: Trends and Implications. USDA, CRS Report RL 30331 October: Washington DC.
Section
Articles