The Genetic Engineering of Food and the Failure of Science – Part 1: The Development of a Flawed Enterprise



Published Jan 15, 2009
Don Lotter


A major conflict has developed in science and society between promoters and opponents of transgenic foods. Food, feed, and fiber products derived from transgenic agricultural crops are presented here as a different case from bacterial, industrial, and pharmaceutical crop transgenics and should be parsed from the larger transgenics industry for comprehensive re-evaluation and market roll-back. Reviewed is the development of the crop transgenics industry; the early influence of the biotechnology industry over the US federal regulatory agencies in the context of the development of minimal regulation; the basic technology of plant transgenics; the main transgenic crops, traits, and producing countries; consumer resistance to transgenic foods; industry problems with shrinking investments; the worldwide promotion of transgenic crops; and ecological issues of transgenic crops. Flaws in the one gene–one protein model, the foundation of transgenics, are reviewed in the context of the recent and ongoing restructuring of the science of genetics. Research on the mutational consequences of plant transgenics and its phenotypic ramifications such as allergens and novel proteins is discussed. Major research findings and ‘red flag’ incidents in the history of transgenic foods and feeds are reviewed that reflect the flaws in the genetic foundations of transgenics.

How to Cite

Lotter, D. 2009. The Genetic Engineering of Food and the Failure of Science – Part 1: The Development of a Flawed Enterprise . The International Journal of Sociology of Agriculture and Food. 16, 1 (Jan. 2009), 31-49. DOI:
Abstract 72 | PDF Downloads 17


AFrICAn Centre For BIoSAFetY (2007) Monsanto’s Genetically Modified Drought Tolerant Maize in South Africa.
African Centre for Biosafety, 1 May, published online , accessed 2 February 2008.
AGLIonBY, J. (2004) Filipino islanders blame GM crop for mystery sickness, The Guardian, 3 March.
BAUe, W. (2003) Innovest report identifies business risk of genetic engineering for Monsanto investors, Sustainability Investment News, 1 May, published online , accessed 2 February 2008.
BeCKer, e., AnD BArBoZA, D. (2003) Battle over biotechnology intensifies trade war, The New York Times, 29 May.
BenBrooK, C. (2004) Genetically Engineered Crops and Pesticide Use in the United States: The First Nine Years.
Biotech Infonet technical Paper number 7, published online .
BenBrooK, C. (2005) Rust, Resistance, Run Down Soils, and Rising Costs - Problems Facing Soybean Producers in Argentina. Ag Biotech Infonet technical Paper no. 8, published online .
BIoSCIenCe reSoUrCe ProJeCt (2007) Rethinking the Risks of Viral Transgenes in Plants. Bioscience resource Project Commentary, 30 november, published online , accessed 31 January 2008.
BoK, D. (2003) Universities in the Marketplace: The Commercialization of Higher Education. Princeton, nJ: Princeton University Press.
Brenner, C. (2004) Telling Transgenic Technology Tales: Lessons from the Agricultural Biotechnology Support Project (ABSP) Experience. International Service for the Acquisition of Agri-Biotech Applications, ISAAA Brief no. 31, , published online , accessed 2 February 2008.
BUrCHer, S. and Ho, M.W. (2007) Scientists and MEPs for a GM free Europe. ISIS report 21/06/07, Institute for Science in Society, published online , accessed 2 February 2008.
CAroLInA-VIrGInIA FArMer (2007) Palmer amaranth resistance threat to cotton industry, Carolina-Virginia Farmer, 30 March.
CArUSo, D. (2007a) A challenge to gene theory, a tougher look at biotech, The New York Times, 1 July.
CArUSo, D. (2007) How to confine the plants of the future?, The New York Times, 8 April.
CHAPeLA, I. and QUISt, D. (2001) transgenic DnA introgressed into traditional maize landraces in oaxaca, Mexico, Nature, 414(6863), pp. 541–543.
CHAUDHArY, K.B. (2007) India’s farming crisis, New Agriculturalist, March, published online , accessed 2 February 2008.
CoLLonIer C., BertHIer, G., BoYer, F., DUPLAn, M., FernAnDeZ, S., KeBDAnI, n., KoBILInSKY, A., roMAnUK, M. and BertHeAU, Y. (2003) Characterization of commercial GMO inserts: a source of useful material to study genome fluidity. Poster presented at ICPMB: International Congress for Plant Molecular Biology, Barcelona, 23–28th June 2003, published online , accessed 2 February 2008.
DALton, r. (2008) Modified genes spread to local maize: findings reignite debate over genetically modified crops, Nature, 456(7219), p. 149.
DoMInGo, J.L. (2007) toxicity studies of genetically modified plants: a review of the published literature, Critical Reviews in Food Science and Nutrition, 47(8), pp. 721–733.
eArtHJUStICe (2006) Federal Court Rules Biopharm Permits Issued Illegally in Hawai’i, Press release, 14 August, published online , accessed 31 January 2008.
eAStHAM, K. and SWeet, J. (2002) Genetically Modified Organisms (GMOs): The Significance of Gene Flow through Pollen Transfer: A Review and Interpretation of Published Literature and Recent/Current Research. environmental Issue report no. 28, european environment Agency, 21 March, published online , accessed 2 February 2008.
eICHenWALD, K. (2001) redesigning nature: hard lessons learned; biotechnology food: from the lab to a debacle, The New York Times, 25 Jan.
eICHenWALD, K. and KoLAtA, G. (2001) Biotechnology food: from the lab to a debacle, The New York Times, 25 January.
enCoDe ProJeCt ConSortIUM (2007) Identification and analysis of functional elements in 1% of the human genome by the enCoDe pilot project, Nature, 447(7146), pp. 799–816.
erMAKoVA, I.V. (2006a) Genetically modified soy leads to the decrease of weight and high mortality of rat pups of the first generation. Preliminary studies, EcosInform, 1, 4–9 (in russian).
erMAKoVA, I.V. (2006b) Genetically modified organisms and biological risks, in: W. Amman, J. Haig, C.
Huovinen, M. Stoker (eds) Proceedings of International Disaster Reduction Conference, Davos, Switzerland, August 27-September 1, 2006, Davos: IDrC, pp.168–171.
erMAKoVA, I.V. and BArSKoV, I.V. (2006) Influence of diet with the soy modified by the gene CP4 ePSPS on physiological state of rats and their offspring, Agrarian russia 2006, in press.
etZKoWItZ, H. (2005) the rise of the entrepreneurial university, International Journal of Contemporary Sociology, (42)1, pp. 28–43.
eWen, S.W.B. and PUSZtAI, A. (1999) effect of diets containing genetically modified potatoes expressing Galanthus nivalis lectin on rat small intestine, The Lancet, 354, pp. 1353–1354.
eYre, C. (2007) GM thai rice on sale soon?, 13 September 2007, published online , accessed 2 February 2008.
FernAnDeZ-CorneJo, J. and MCBrIDe, W. (2002) Adoption of Bioengineered Crops. erS USDA Agricultural economic report Aer810, Washington, DC: economic research Service.
FIG, D. (2007) Is Africa Being Bullied into Growing GM Crops? Science and Development network, 27 June, published online , accessed 2 Feb. 2008.
FInAMore A., roSeLLI, M., BrIttI, S., MonAStrA, G., AMBrA, r., tUrrInI, A. and MenGHerI, e. (2008) Intestinal and peripheral immune response to Mon810 maize ingestion in weaning and old mice, Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry, 56(23), pp. 11533–11539.
FLoreS, S., SAxenA, D. and StotZKY, G. (2005) transgenic Bt plants decompose less in soil than non-Bt plants, Soil Biology and Biochemistry, 37(6), pp. 1073–1082.
FreeMAn, L. (2005) GM food legislation: modified foods in the halls of power, GeneWatch, 18(1), published online , accessed 2 Feb. 2008.
FreeSe, W. and SCHUBert, D. (2004) Safety testing and regulation of genetically engineered foods, Biotechnology and Genetic Engineering Reviews, 21, pp. 299–324.
FrIenDS oF tHe eArtH (2004) GM Crop Safety Tests ‘Flawed’, New Scientific Paper Shows Approval of Monsanto's GM Corn Questioned. Friends of the earth press release, 16 nov., published online , accessed 2 Feb. 2008.
FrIeSen, L., neLSon, A. and VAn ACKer, r. (2003) evidence of contamination of pedigreed canola (Brassica napus) seedlots in Western Canada with genetically engineered herbicide resistance traits, Agronomy Journal, 95, pp. 1342–1347.
GHoSH, P. (2007) Pest attack: Punjab Bt cotton crop may be set back by 25%, Mint/Wall Street Journal, 31 Aug., published online , accessed 2 Feb. 2008.
GIBBS, W.W. (2003) the unseen genome: gems among the junk, Scientifc American, 289(55), 26–33.
GUerIn, B. (2005) the seeds of a bribery scandal in Indonesia, Asia Times, 20 Jan.
GUPtA, A., MUnDLAI, A. and nIDHI, A. (2005) Impact of Bt Cotton on Farmers’ Health. Investigation report oct.–Dec. 2005, published online , accessed 2 Feb. 2008.
HAMILton, D.P. (2004) Biotech's dismal bottom line: more than $40 billion in losses, Wall Street Journal, 20 May.
HeIneMAnn, J. (2007) A Typology of the Effects of Transgene Flow on the Conservation and Sustainable Use of Genetic Resources. Background study paper no. 35 June. rome: Un FAo Commission on Genetic resources for Food and Agriculture.
HernánDeZ, M., PLA, M., eSteVe, t., PrAt, S., PUIGDoMèneCH, P. and FerrAnDo, A. (2003) A specific realtime quantitative PCr detection system for event Mon810 in maize YieldGard based on the 3’-transgene integration sequence, Transgenic Research, 12, pp. 179–189.
HILLBeCK, A. and SCHMIDt, J. (2006) Another view on Bt proteins: how specific are they and what else might they do?, Biopesticides International, 2(1), pp. 1–5.
Ho, M. (2006) Mass Deaths in Sheep Grazing on Bt Cotton. ISIS Press release 03/05/06, published online , accessed 2 Feb. 2008.
Ho, M. (2007) Philanthropy Gates style, Science in Society, 35, pp. 4–8, published online , accessed 2 Feb. 2008.
JAkARTA POST (2007) Govt urged to get serious about promoting biotechnology, The Jakarta Post, 19 July.
JoStA, P., SHUrLeYB, D., CULPePPerB, S., roBertSB, P., nICHoLSC, r., reeVeSC, J. and AntHonYD, S. (2008) economic comparison of transgenic and nontransgenic cotton production systems in Georgia, Agronomy Journal, 100, pp. 42–51.
KLeInMAn, D.L. (2003) Impure Cultures: University Biology and the World of Commerce. Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin Press.
KLeter, G.A. and PeIJnenBUrG, A. (2002) Screening of transgenic proteins expressed in transgenic food crops for the presence of short amino acid sequences identical to potential, Ige – binding linear epitopes of allergens, BMC Structural Biology, 2(8).
KrIMSKY, S. (2003) Science in the Private Interest: Has the Lure of Profits Corrupted Biomedical Research? Lanham, MD: rowman and Littlefield.
LAtHAM, J. and SteInBreCHer, r. (2004) Gene flow (B): horizontal gene transfer of viral inserts from GM plants to viruses, technical Paper for GM Science review Meeting of the royal Society of edinburgh ‘GM Gene Flow: Scale and Consequences for Agriculture and the environment’, published online , accessed 2 Feb. 2008.
LAtHAM, J.r., WILSon, A.K. and SteInBreCHer, r.A. (2006) the mutational consequences of plant transformation, Journal of Biomedicine and Biotechnology, 2006, pp. 1–7.
LAtHAM, J. and WILSon, A. (2007) transcomplementation and synergism in plants: implications for viral transgenes?, Molecular Plant Pathology, 8(6), pp. 1–19.
LéGère, A. (2005) risks and consequences of gene flow from herbicide-resistant crops: canola Brassica napus L. as a case study, Pest Management Science, 61(3), pp. 292–300.
LeYDeSDorFF, L. and etZKoWItZ, H. (2001) the transformation of university-industry-government relations, Electronic Journal of Sociology, 4(5), published online .
LoPeZ VILLAr, J., FreeSe, A., BeBB, A., BASSeY, n., AMénDoLA, C. and FerreIrA, M. (2007) An analysis of the global performance of GM crops (1996–2006). Friends of the earth ‘Who benefits from GM crops?’ issue 111, Jan.
LoPeZ-VILLAr, J. and FreeSe, W. (2008) The Rise in Pesticide Use. Friends of the earth International/Center for Food Safety ‘Who Benefits from GM Crops?’ issue 112, Jan., published online , accessed 12 Dec. 2008.
Lotter, D. (2003) organic agriculture, Journal of Sustainable Agriculture, 21(4), pp. 59–128.
MALAteStA, M., CAPorALonI, C., GAVAUDAn, S., roCCHI, M., SerAFInI, S., tIBerI, C. and GAZZAneLLI, G. (2002) Ultrastructural morphometrical and immunocytochemical analyses of hepatocyte nuclei from mice fed on genetically modified soybean, Cell Structure and Function, 27(4), pp. 173–180.
MArVIer, M. (2007) Pharmaceutical crops have a mixed outlook in California, California Agriculture, 61(2), pp. 59–66.
MArVIer, M. and VAn ACKer, r. (2005) Can crop transgenes be kept on a leash?, Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment, 3(2), pp. 93–100.
MCInerneY, C., BIrD, n. and nUCCI, M. (2004) the flow of scientific knowledge from lab to the lay public: the case of genetically modified food, Science Communication, 26, pp. 44–74.
MeLLMAn GroUP, InC. (2006) Public Sentiment About Genetically Modified Foods (2006). Pew Initiative on Food and Biotechnology, published online , accessed 2 Feb. 2008.
MeLLon, M. and rISSLer, J. (2003) environmental effects of genetically modified food crops, recent experiences, Paper presented at conference ‘Genetically Modified Foods – the American experience’, royal Veterinary and Agricultural University, Copenhagen, Denmark, 12–13 June, published online , accessed 2 Feb. 2008.
Merrett, n. (2007) GM food industry eyes growth in the east,, 8 March, published online , accessed 2 Feb. 2008.
MetZLAFF, M., o’DeLL, M., CLUSter, P.D. and FLAVeLL, r.B. (1997) rnA-mediated rnA degradation and chalcone synthase A silencing in petunia, Cell, 88(6), pp. 845–854.
MoHABBAt, L. (2007) Skin allergy and pulmonary problems reported with Bt cotton, Desh Sewak, 16 oct. (in Punjabi), 21 oct., published online in english trans. , accessed 2 Feb.2008.
MYerSon, A.r. (1997) Seeds of discontent: cotton growers say strain cuts yields, The New York Times, 19 nov.
MYHre, M.r., Fenton, K.A., eGGert, J., nIeLSen, K.M. and trAAVIK, t. (2006) the 35S CaMV plant virus promoter is active in human enterocyte-like cells, European Food Research and Technology, 222(1–2), pp. 185–193.
norDLee, J.A., tAYLor, S.L., toWnSenD, J.A., tHoMAS, L.A. and BUSH, r.K. (1996) Identification of a Brazilnut allergen in transgenic soybeans, New England Journal of Medicine, 334(11), pp. 688–692. oWen, M. and ZeLAYA, I. (2005) Herbicide-resistant crops and weed resistance to herbicides, Pest Management Science, 61, pp. 301–311.
PLAntMAnAGeMent netWorK (2007) Giant ragweed seventh U.S. weed confirmed resistant to glyphosate, Crop Management, 24 Jan., published online , accessed 2 Feb. 2008.
PoLLACK, A. (2007) U.S. agency violated law in seed case, judge rules, The New York Times, 14 Feb.
PrAKASH, C.S. (2002) Joint Statement in Support of Scientific Discourse in Mexican GM Maize Scandal. AgbioWorld, published online , accessed May 7, 2009.
PrenSA LAtInA (2007) Mexico under pressure to grow transgenic plants, Prensa Latina press release, 20 Aug, published online , accessed 2 Feb. 2008.
PreSCott, V.e., CAMPBeLL, P.M., Moore, A., MAtteS, J., rotHenBerG, M., FoSter, P.S., HIGGInS, t.J.V. and HoGAn, S.P. (2005) transgenic expression of bean ?-amylase inhibitor in peas results in altered structure and immunogenicity, Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry, 53(23), pp. 9023–9030.
PreSS, e. andWASHBUrn, J. (2000) the kept university, Atlantic Monthly, 285(3).
QAIM, M. and ZILBerMAn, D. (2003) Yield effects of genetically modified crops in developing countries, Science, 299, p. 900.
roBInSon, C. (2004) Biotech Investment Busy Going Nowhere. Institute of Science in Society press release 13 July, published online , accessed 2 Feb. 2008.
roSAtI, A., BoGAnI, P., SAntArLASCI, A. and BUIAttI, M. (2008) Characterisation of 4’ transgene insertion site and derived mrnAs in Mon810 YieldGard maize, Plant Molecular Biology, 67, pp. 271–281.
roSI-MArSHALL, e.J., tAnK, J.L., roYer, t.V., WHILeS, M.r., eVAnS-WHIte, M., CHAMBerS, C., GrIFFItHS, n.A., PoKeLSeK, J. and StePHen, M.L. (2007) toxins in transgenic crop byproducts may affect headwater stream ecosystems, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 104: pp. 16204–16208
rYAn, r. (2007) More than 70% of europeans are against GM food, say surveys, Irish Examiner, 15 Sept.
SCHUBert, D.r. (2008) the problem with nutritionally enhanced plants, Journal of Medicinal Food, 11(4), p. 601.
SeeDQUeSt (2000) Smaller Farms Often See Smaller Profits from Genetically Modified Crops, University of Wisconsin-
Madison Study Shows, Seedquest Press release, 27 Dec., published online , accessed 2 Feb. 2008.
SerALInI, G. e., CeLLIer, D. and De VenDoMoIS, J.S. (2007) new analysis of a rat feeding study with a genetically modified maize reveals signs of hepatorenal toxicity, Archives of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology, 52(4), pp. 596–602.
SHeeHAn, C. (2006) Scientists see spike in kids’ food allergies, Chicago Tribune, 9 June.
SInGH, C.K., oJKA, A., KAMLe, S. and KACHrU, D.n. (2007) Assessment of cry1Ab transgene cassette in commercial Bt corn Mon810: gene, event, construct & GMo specific concurrent characterization, Nature Protocols, published online .
SLAUGHter, S. and rHoADeS, G. (2004) Academic Capitalism and the New Economy : Markets, State, and Higher Education. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
SMItH, J. (2003) Seeds of Deception. Fairfield, IA: Yes Books.
SMItH, J. (2007) Genetically engineered foods may cause rising food allergies – Part 2. Spilling the Beans, Seeds of Deception Newsletter, June, published onlint , accessed 2 Feb. 2008.
Stone, G.D. (2002) Biotechnology and auicide in India, Anthropology News, 43(5).
Stone, G. (2007) Agricultural deskilling and the spread of genetically modified cotton in Warangal, Current Anthropology, 48(1), pp. 67–103.
tABASHnIK, B.e., CArrIère, Y., DenneHY, t.J., MorIn, S., SISterSon, M.S., roUSH, r.t., SHeLton, A.M. and ZHAo, J.Z. (2003) Insect resistance to transgenic Bt crops: lessons from the laboratory and field, Journal of Economic Entomology, 96, pp. 1031–1038.
trAAVIK, t. and HeIneMAnn, J. (2007) Genetic Engineering and Omitted Health Research: Still No Answers to Ageing Questions. tWn Biotechnology & Biosafety Series 7. Penang, Malaysia: third World network.
VACHer, C., WeIS, A.e., HerMAnn, D., KoSSLer, t., YoUnG, C. and HoCHBerG, M. (2004) Impact of ecological factors on the initial invasion of Bt transgenes into wild populations of birdseed rape (Brassica rapa), Theoretical and Applied Genetics, 109(4), pp. 806–814.
VAn LAreBeKe, n., GeneteLLo, C., SCHeLL, J., SCHILPeroort, r.A., HerMAnS, A.K., HernALSteenS, J.P. and VAn MontAGU, M. (1975) Acquisition of tumour-inducing ability by non-oncogenic agrobacteria as a result of plasmid transfer, Nature, 255(5511), pp. 742–743.
VeLIMIroV, A., BInter, C. and ZenteK, J. (2008) Biological Effects of Transgenic Maize Nk603xMON810 Fed in Long Term Reproduction Studies in Mice. Vienna: Bundesministerium für Gesundheit, Familie und Jugend.
WAnG, S., JUSt, D.r. and PInStrUP-AnDerSen, P. (2006) tarnishing silver bullets: bt technology adoption, bounded rationality and the outbreak of secondary pest infestations in China, Paper presented at the American Agricultural economics Association Annual Meeting Long Beach, CA, 22–26 July, published online , accessed 2 Feb. 2008.
WArWICK, S.I., LeGere, A., SIMArD, M.J. and JAMeS, t. (2007) Do escaped transgenes persist in nature? the case of an herbicide resistance transgene in a weedy Brassica rapa population, Molecular Ecology, 17(5), pp. 1387–1395
WeISS, r. (2007) Probe into tainted rice ends: USDA unable to find explanation or determine blame, Washington Post, 6 oct.
WeLSH, r. and GLennA, L. (2007) Considering the role of the university in conducting research on agribiotechnologies, Social Studies of Science, 36(6), pp. 929–942.
WISner, r. (2005) Genetically Modified Wheat is Still a Market Risk: Market Impacts from Commercializing Round-Up Ready® Wheat. Western organization of resource Councils press release, May, published online , accessed 31 Jan. 2008.
YoSHIMUrA, Y., BeCKIe, H. and MAtSUo, K. (2006) transgenic oilseed rape along transportation routes and port of Vancouver in western Canada, Environmental Biosafety Research, 5(2), pp. 67–75.
ZoLLA, L., rInALDUCCI, S., AntonIoLI, P. and rIGHettI, P.G. (2008) Proteomics as a complementary tool for identifying unintended side effects occurring in transgenic maize seeds as a result of genetic modifications, Journal of Proteome Research, 7(5), pp. 1850–1861.
Work in Progress