Dynamics of Power and Cooperation in Rural Development: The Case of Chianina Beef Production in Italy

##plugins.themes.bootstrap3.article.main##

##plugins.themes.bootstrap3.article.sidebar##

Published Jun 4, 2009
Yoko Kanemasu Roberta Sonnino

Abstract

This article contributes to the theorization of the much-debated ‘paradigm shift’ from conventional agri-industrialism towards sustainable rural development through the adoption of an actor-oriented approach that focuses on the practices, initiatives and experiences of rural actors themselves. Building on existing conceptualizations of rural actors as active agents, we analyse cooperative relations amongst quality meat producers in central Italy to shed light onto the dynamics of their collective interventions. Our case study demonstrates that seemingly ‘alternative’ rural development processes do not necessarily represent a smooth transition towards a new paradigm. Whilst producers have the capacity to collectively negotiate the pressures of the conventional agri-food system, their agency encompasses also conscious attempts to manoeuvre a highly ambiguous relationship with conventional markets to their advantage. Such ‘empowerment’ is also far from unproblematic. Collective actions provide producers with a degree of power, which, however, is subject to an asymmetrical distribution that seems to parallel that of agri-industrialism. In other words, producers’ collective action against the dominant forces of agro-industrial globalization is a contested process of allocation of power over productive relations and the market. Our analysis hence problematises the notion of ‘paradigm shift’ and calls for further research that critically examines the power differentials that reside in different dimensions of rural development practices.

How to Cite

[1]
Kanemasu , Y. and Sonnino, R. 2009. Dynamics of Power and Cooperation in Rural Development: The Case of Chianina Beef Production in Italy . The International Journal of Sociology of Agriculture and Food. 16, 2 (Jun. 2009), 36-53. DOI:https://doi.org/10.48416/ijsaf.v16i2.271.
Abstract 23 | PDF Downloads 16

##plugins.themes.bootstrap3.article.details##

References
aLLen, P. (1999) Reweaving the food security net: mediating entitlement and entrepreneurship, Agriculture and Human Values, 16, pp. 117–129.
aLLen, P. and koVaCH, m. (2000) the capitalist composition of organic: the potential of markets in fulfilling the promise of organic agriculture, Agriculture and Human Values, 17, pp. 221–232.
aLLen, P., FiZsimmons, m., GooDman, m. andWaRneR, k. (2003) shifting plates in the agrifood landscape: the tectonics of alternative agrifood initiatives in California, Journal of Rural Studies, 19, pp. 61–75.
aLonso mieLGo, a.m., seViLLa GuZmán, e., JiméneZ RomeRa, m. and GuZmán CasaDo, G. (2001) Rural development and ecological management of endogenous resources: the case of mountain olive groves in Los Pedroches Comarca (spain), Journal of Environmental Policy and Planning, 3, pp. 163–175.
anabiC (nationaLassoCiation oF bReeDeRs oF itaLian beeF) (2003) Attivitá Sociale e Tecnica 2003. Perugia: anabiC.
banks, J. and maRsDen, t. (2000) integrating agri-environment policy, farming systems and rural development: tir Cymen in Wales, Sociologia Ruralis, 40(4), pp. 466–480.
banks, J. and maRsDen, t. (2001) the nature of rural development: the organic potential, Journal of Environmental Policy and Planning, 3, pp. 103–121.
beZanson, k. and CaRteR, e. (2006) Public Policy and Social Reproduction: Gendering Social Capital. ottawa, Canada: status of Women Canada.
bRuCkmeieR, k. (2000) LeaDeR in Germany and the discourse of autonomous regional development, Sociologia Ruralis, 40(2), pp. 219–227.
bRunoRi, G. and Rossi, a. (2000) synergy and coherence through collective action: some insights from wine routes in tuscany, Sociologia Ruralis, 40(4), pp. 409–423.
buCk, D., GetZ, C. and GutHman, J. (1997) From farm to table: the organic vegetable commodity chain of northern California, Sociologia Ruralis, 37(1), pp. 3–20.
buRton, R.J.F. (2004) seeing through the ‘good farmer’s’ eyes: towards developing an understanding of the social symbolic value of ‘productivist’ behaviour, Sociologia Ruralis, 44(2), pp. 195–215.
buRton, R.J.F. andWiLson, G. (2006) injecting social psychology theory into conceptualisations of agricultural agency: towards a postproductivist farmer self-identity?, Journal of Rural Studies, 22, pp. 95–115.
butteL, F.H., LaRson, o.F. and GiLLesPie, G.W. (1990) The Sociology of Agriculture. new York, nY: Greenwood Press.
CHase, J. (2003) Regional prestige: cooperatives and agroindustrial identity in southwest Goiás, brazil, Agriculture and Human Values, 20, pp. 37–51.
CHLouPkoVa, J., sVenDsen, G.L.H. and sVenDsen, G.t. (2003) building and destroying social capital: the case of cooperative movements in Denmark and Poland, Agriculture and Human Values, 20, 241–252.
De bRuin, R. (1995) Local cooperatives as carriers of endogenous development, in: J.D. Van DeR PLoeG and G. Van DiJk (eds) Beyond Modernisation: The Impact of Endogenous Rural Development, assen: Van Gorcum, pp.256–273.
De Roest, k. and menGHi, a. (2000) Reconsidering ‘traditional’ food: the case of Parmigiano Reggiano cheese, Sociologia Ruralis, 40(4), pp. 439–451. De Roest, k., montanaRi, C., CoRRaDini, e. and FeDeRiCi, C. (2005) Production costs and profitability of the farming of Chianina cattle. Paper presented at the 4th World italian beef Cattle Congress, italy, 29 april–
1 may.
DuPuis, e.m. and GooDman, D. (2005) should we go ‘home’ to eat? toward a reflexive politics of localism, Journal of Rural Studies, 21, pp. 359–371.
eVans, n., moRRis, C. andWinteR, m. (2002) Conceptualising agriculture: a critique of post-productivism as the new orthodoxy, Progress in Human Geography, 26(3), pp. 313–332.
Fine, b. and LaPaVitsas, C. (2004) social capital and capitalist economies, South Eastern Europe Journal of Economics, 1, 17–34.
FRasCaReLLi, a. (2005) Potere di mercato e valore aggiuno nelle filiere tracciate delle carni bovine di qualita, Paper presented at the 4th World italian beef Cattle Congress, italy, 29 april–1 may.
GooDman, D. (2000) organic and conventional agriculture: materialising discourse and agro-ecological managerialism, Agriculture and Human Values, 17, pp. 215–219.
GooDman, D. (2004) Rural europe redux? Reflections on alternative agro-food networks and paradigm change, Sociologia Ruralis, 44(1), pp. 3–16.
GoRman, m., mannion, J., kinseLLa, J. and boGue, P. (2001) Connecting environmental management and farm household livelihoods: the rural environment protection scheme in ireland, Journal of Environmental Policy and Planning, 3, pp. 137–147.
GutHman, J. (1998) Regulating meaning, appropriating nature: the codification of California organic agriculture, Antipode, 30(2), pp. 135–154.
GutHman, J. (2000) Raising organic: an agro-ecological assessment of grower practices in California, Agriculture and Human Values, 17, pp. 257–266.
GutHman, J. (2004) the trouble with ‘organic lite’ in California: a rejoinder to the ‘conventionalisation’ debate, Sociologia Ruralis, 44(3), pp. 301–316.
HiGGins, V. (2006) Re-figuring the problem of farmer agency in agri-food studies: a translation approach, aGRiCuLtuRe anD Human VaLues, 23, pp. 51–62.
HoGGaRt, k. and PaniaGua, a. (2001) What rural restructuring?, Journal of Rural Studies, 17(1), pp. 41–62.
HoLLoWaY, L., Cox, R., Venn, L., kneaFseY, m., DoWLeR, e. and tuomainen, H. (2006) managing sustainable farmed landscape through ‘alternative’ food networks: a case study from italy, Geographical Journal, 172(3), pp. 219–229.
JaRosZ, L. (2000) understanding agri-food networks as social relations, Agriculture and Human Values, 17, pp. 279–283.
kinseLLa, J., boGue, P. mannion, J. and WiLson, s. (2002) Cost reduction for small-scale dairy farms in County Clare, in: J. D. Van DeR PLoeG, a. LonG and J. banks (eds) Living Countrysides: Rural Development Processes in Europe: The State of the Art, Doetinchem: elsevier, pp.150–158.
kniCkeL, k. (2001) the marketing of Rhöngold milk: an example of the reconfiguration of natural relations with agricultural production and consumption, Journal of Environmental Policy and Planning, 3, pp. 123–136.
kniCkeL, k. and RentinG, H. (2000) methodological and conceptual issues in the study of multifunctionality and rural development, Sociologia Ruralis, 40, pp. 512–528.
Lamine, C. (2005) settling shared uncertainties: local partnerships between producers and consumers, Sociologia Ruralis, 45(4), pp. 324–345.
LaW, a. andmooneY, G. (2006) the maladies of social capital ii: resisting neo-liberal conformism, Critique, 34(3), pp. 253–268.
Lee, J., áRnason, a., niGHtinGaLe, a. and sHuCksmitH, m. (2005) networking: social capital and identities in european rural development, Sociologia Ruralis, 45(4), pp. 269–283.
Le HeRon, R. (1993) Globalized Agriculture: Political Choice. oxford: Pergamon.
LonG, n. (1997) agency and constraint, perceptions and practice: a theoretical position, in: H. De Haan and n. LonG (eds) Images and Realities of Rural Life: Wageningen Perspectives on Rural Transformations, assen: Van Gorcum, pp.1–20.
LonG, n. (2001) Development Sociology: Actor Perspectives. London: Routledge.
LoWe, P., muRDoCH, J. and WaRD, n. (1995) networks in rural development: beyond exogenous and endogenous models, in: J.D. Van DeR PLoeG and G. Van DiJk (eds) Beyond Modernisation: The Impact of Endogenous Rural Development, assen: Van Gorcum, pp. 87–105.
maRsDen, t. (2003) The Condition of Rural Sustainability. assen: Royal Van Gorcum.
maRsDen, t. (2006) the road towards sustainable rural development: issues of theory, policy and practice in a european context, in: P. CLoke, t. maRsDen and P. mooneY (eds) Handbook of Rural Studies, London: sage Publications, pp. 201–212.
maRsDen, t.k. and muRDoCH, J. (2006) introduction: between the local and the global: confronting complexity in the contemporary food sector, in: t. maRsDen and J. muRDoCH (eds) Between the Local and the Global: Confronting Complexity in the Contemporary Food Sector, amsterdam: elsevier, pp. 1–8.
maRsDen, t., banks, J. and bRistoW, G. (2000) Food supply chain approaches: exploring their role in rural development, Sociologia Ruralis, 40(4), pp. 424–37.
maRsDen, t., banks, J., RentinG, H. and Van DeR PLoeG, J.D. (2001) the road towards sustainable rural development: issues of theory, policy and research practice, Journal of Environmental Policy and Planning, 3, pp. 75–83.
maRsDen, t., sonnino, R. and moRGan, k. (2008) alternative food networks in comparative perspective: exploring their contribution in creating sustainable spaces, in: t. maRsDen (ed.) Sustainable Communities: New Spaces for Planning, Participation and Engagement, amsterdam: elsevier, pp. 255–284.
mCaReaVeY, R. (2006) Getting close to the action: the micro-politics of rural development, Sociologia Ruralis, 46(2), pp. 85–103.
mCmiCHaeL, P. (2000) Development and Social Change: A Global Perspective. thousand oaks, Ca: Pine Forge Press.
mieLe, m. and PinDuCCiu, D. (2001) a market for nature: linking the production and consumption of organics in tuscany, Journal of Environmental Policy and Planning, 3, pp. 149–162.
moRGan, k., maRsDen, t. and muRDoCH, J. (2006) Worlds of Food: Place, Power, and Provenance in the Food Chain. oxford: oxford university Press.
moRRis, C. and PotteR, C. (1995) Recruiting the new conservationists: farmers' adoption of agri-environmental schemes in the uk, Journal of Rural Studies, 11, pp. 51–63.
muRDoCH, J., WaRD, n. and LoWe, P. (1994) sustainable agriculture and endogenous development: a sociopolitical perspective, in: J.D. Van DeR PLoeG anda. LonG (eds) Born From Within: Practice and Perspectives of Endogenous Rural Development, assen, netherlands: Van Gorcum, pp. 262–279.
muRDoCH, J., maRsDen, t. and banks, J. (2000) Quality, nature and embeddedness: some theoretical considerations in the context of the food sector, Economic Geography, 76(2), pp. 107–125.
RaY, C. (2000) the eu LeaDeR Programme: rural development laboratory, Sociologia Ruralis, 40(2), pp. 163–171.
RentinG, H. and Van DeR PLoeG, J.D. (2001) Reconnecting nature, farming and society: environmental cooperatives in the netherlands as institutional arrangements for creating coherence, Journal of Environmental Policy and Planning, 3, pp. 85–101.
RentinG, H., maRsDen, t. and banks, J. (2003) understanding alternative food networks: exploring the role of short food supply chains in rural development, Environment and Planning A, 35, pp. 393–411.
sanZ CanãDa, J. andmaCías VáZQueZ, a. (2005) Quality certification, institutions and innovation in local agro-food systems: protected designations of origin of olive oil in spain, Journal of Rural Studies, 21, pp. 475–486.
sassateLLi, R. and sCott, a. (2001) novel food, new markets and trust regimes: responses to the erosion of consumers’ confidence in austria, italy and the uk, European Societies, 3(2), pp. 213–244.
sCott, k., PaRk, J. and CoCkLin, C. (2000) From ‘sustainable rural communities’ to ‘social sustainability’: giving voice to diversity in mangakahia Valley, new Zealand, Journal of Rural Studies, 16, pp. 433–446.
sHoRtaLL, s. (2004) social or economic goals, civic inclusion or exclusion? an analysis of rural development theory and practice, Sociologia Ruralis, 44(1), pp. 109–123.
sHuCksmitH, m. (1993) Farm household behaviour and the transition to post-productivism, Journal of Agricultural Economics, 44, pp. 566–478.
sHuCksmitH, m. (2000) endogenous development, social capital and social inclusion: perspectives from LeaDeR in the uk, Sociologia Ruralis, 40(2), pp. 208–218.
sLanGen, L.H G., Van kooten, G.C. and suCHánek, P. (2004) institutions, social capital and agricultural change in Central and eastern europe, Journal of Rural Studies, 20, pp. 245–256.
sobeLs, J., CuRtis, a. and LoCkie, s. (2001) the role of Landcare Group networks in rural australia: exploring the contribution of social capital, Journal of Rural Studies, 17, pp. 265–276.
sonnino, R. (2007) embeddedness in action: saffron and the making of the local in southern tuscany, Agriculture and Human Values, 24(1), pp. 61–74.
sonnino, R. (2009) Quality food, public procurement, and sustainable development: the school meal revolution in Rome, Environment and Planning A, 41(2), pp. 425–440
sonnino, R. andmaRsDen, t. (2006a) beyond the divide: rethinking relationships between alternative and conventional food networks in europe, Journal of Economic Geography, 6, pp. 181–199.
sonnino, R. andmaRsDen, t. (2006b) alternative food networks in the south West of england: towards a new agrarian eco-economy?, in: t. maRsDen and J. muRDoCH (eds) Between the Local and the Global: Confronting Complexity in the Contemporary Agri-Food Sector, oxford: elsevier, pp. 299–322.
sVenDsen, G.L.H. and sVenDsen, G.t. (2000) measuring social capital: the Danish co-operative dairy movement, Sociologia Ruralis, 40(1), pp. 72–86.
tReGeaR, a. (2003) From stilton to Vimto: using food history to re-think typical products in rural development, Sociologia Ruralis, 43(2), pp. 91–107.
Van DeR meuLen, H. and VentuRa, F. (1995) methods for identifying and reinforcing endogenous rural development: experiences from umbria, in: J.D. Van DeR PLoeG and G. Van DiJk (eds) Beyond Modernisation: The Impact of Endogenous Rural Development, assen: Van Gorcum, pp. 147–178.
Van DeR PLoeG, J.D. (1992) the reconstitution of locality: technology and labour in modern agriculture, in: t. maRsDen, P. LoWe and s. WHatmoRe (eds) Labour and Locality: Uneven Development and the Rural Labour Process, London: David Fulton, pp. 19–43.
Van DeR PLoeG, J.D. (1993) Rural sociology and the new agrarian question: a perspective from the netherlands, Sociologia Ruralis, 33(2), pp. 140–260.
Van DeR PLoeG, J.D. (1995) From structural development to structural involution: the impact of new development in Dutch agriculture, in: J.D. Van DeR PLoeG and G. Van DiJk (eds) Beyond Modernisation: The Impact of Endogenous Rural Development, assen: Van Gorcum, pp. 109–146.
Van DeR PLoeG, J.D. (2000) Revitalising agriculture: farming economically as starting ground for rural development, Sociologia Ruralis, 40(4), pp. 497–511.
Van DeR PLoeG, J.D. and RentinG, H. (2000) impact and potential: a comparative review of european rural development practices, Sociologia Ruralis, 40(4), pp. 529–543.
Van DeR PLoeG, J.D. and RentinG, H. (2004) behind the ‘redux’: a rejoinder to David Goodman, Sociologia Ruralis, 44(2), pp. 233–242.
Van DeR PLoeG, J.D. and Van DiJk, G. (eds) (1995) Beyond Modernisation: The Impact of Endogenous Rural Development. assen: Van Gorcum.
Van DeR PLoeG, J.D., RentinG, H., bRunoRi, G., kniCkeL, k., mannion, J., maRsDen, t., De Roest, k., seViLLa-GuZmán, e. and VentuRa, F. (2000) Rural development: from practices and policies towards theory, Sociologia Ruralis, 40(4), pp. 391–408.
Van DeR PLoeG, J.D., LonG, a. and banks, J. (2002) Rural development: the state of the art, in: J.D. Van DeR PLoeG, a. LonG and J. banks (eds) Living Countrysides: Rural Development Processes in Europe: The State of the Art, Doetinchem: elsevier, pp. 8–17.
VentuRa, F. andmiLone, P. (2000) theory and practice of multi-product farms: farm butcheries in umbria, Sociologia Ruralis, 40(4), pp. 452–465.
VeRHaeGen, i. and Van HuYLenbRoeCk, G. (2001) Costs and benefits for farmers participating in innovative marketing channels for quality food products, Journal of Rural Studies, 17, pp. 443–456.
WiLson, G.a. (2001) From productivism to post-productivism… and back again? exploring the (un)changed natural and mental landscapes of european agriculture, Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 26(1), pp. 77–102.
WooDHouse, a. (2006) social capital and economic development in regional australia: a case study, Journal of Rural Studies, 22, pp. 83–94.
ZimmeReR, k.s. (2007) agriculture, livelihoods, and globalization: the analysis of new trajectories (and avoidance of just-so stories) of human-environment change and conservation, Agriculture and Human Values, 24, pp. 9–16.
Section
Articles